🎧 Music Roast

Black Mozart

Jon Batiste · Classical / Jazz Crossover

Sizning Mozart albomingizdagi eng yorqin lahza, siz Mozart'ni ijro etishni to'xtatadigan lahza. Vaziyatni o'qing, agar bunga uddasidan chiqolmasangiz, taqrizlarni o'qing.

6.0/ 10
Cynical Sally roasts the music

Jon Batiste mayda g'oyalar bilan shug'ullanmaydi. Uning Batiste Piano Series turkumining ikkinchi jildi Black Mozart June 19 kuni, ataylab Juneteenth bilan bir vaqtga to'g'rilab, Decca yorlig'ida chiqadi va bu Mozart'ni qora amerikalik musiqiy nigoh orqali qaytadan tasavvur qiladigan yakkaxon pianino. Bundan tashqari, bu rejalashtirilgan uchta albomdan faqat birinchisi, Monk'dan ilhomlangan yana ikkita yozuv hali oldinda. Konsepsiya ulkan, ramka ma'noli va shijoat aynan siz kutgan darajada. Qaynaganda, rostakamiga qaynaydi. Country Zart va Molto in Caya Hueso kabi treklarda Batiste'ning ijodkorligi alanga oladi, klassik motivlar soul va gospelga sakraydi, bir lahza Mozart, keyingi lahzada esa Aretha Franklin madhiyasidek hayqiradigan nimadir. Mana shu lahzalarda butun ulug'vor g'oya chinakam o'zini oqlaydi. Lekin gap shundaki, va tanqidchilar ham buni payqashdi. Yozuv Mozart'ni shunchaki sodiqlik bilan qayta talqin qilganda eng tekisidir, Batiste manbani butunlay tashlab, o'zini ijro etganda esa eng jonlisidir. Mozart albomidagi eng ko'p maqtalgan lahza, aynan u Mozart'ni ijro etishni to'xtatadigan lahza. Bu sizga haqiqiy, yaxshiroq albom qayerda yashiringan bo'lganini aniq aytib beradi.

Share the roastTap a card to grab it
Sally roast card 1
PNG
Sally roast card 2
PNG
Sally roast card 3
PNG
The bright side

Konsepsiya chin dildan shijoatkor va Juneteenth ramkasi unga haqiqiy salmoq bag'ishlaydi, o'zining cho'qqisida esa Batiste bir martagina o'lchov ichida asrlar musiqasini boshqa deyarli hech kim urinib ham ko'rmaydigan tarzda bog'laydi.

The issues (2)
01

Faithful when it should be fearless

Critics noted the album is strongest on Country Zart, where Batiste leaves Mozart behind, and flattest in the stretches where it merely reinterprets the source material.

The fix  Trust your own voice. The Batiste originals are the reason anyone presses play, so give them the whole record instead of treating them as detours.

02

A concept doing the heavy lifting

The Juneteenth release date and the Black Mozart framing carry a weight that the straighter, faithful reinterpretations do not always live up to on their own.

The fix  Let the music make the argument the title is making. Fewer dutiful straight readings, more of the bold reinventions that actually justify the concept.

Your turn

Think your track survives me? Drop a link.

A full teardown from €2,99. No mercy.

Printed with disdain · Cynical Sally