Cynical Sally← Contents
Lyrics · How to / How not to

How to Write a Song Lyric (and How Not To)

Most lyrics are a diary entry that found out what 'rhymes with heart' before it found out what it wanted to say.

By Cynical SallyIssue Nº 1

A good lyric is not poetry. Poetry sits still on a page and lets you read it twice. A lyric goes by once, at speed, attached to a melody, and either lands or it doesn't. You don't get a second pass, so every line has to do its job the first time or it's gone.

This is what you getA real Full Truth, in full
Cynical SallyLyrics

The Full Truth

on An indie singer-songwriter's lyrics for a track called 'Paper Hearts'

4.2
out of ten
You rhymed 'apart' with 'heart' twice in the same song, which is less a chorus and more a confession that you ran out before the second verse.
The Investigation
  1. 01

    The chorus is a fridge magnet, not a hook

    Critical

    'Our paper hearts are torn apart' is three dead metaphors holding hands. Paper hearts, torn, apart: none of it is yours, so none of it is felt. Replace the whole image with one real object from the actual relationship and the song stops sounding like every other song.

  2. 02

    Pronoun drift you can hear

    Notable

    Verse one mourns 'the way she'd leave', verse two pleads 'come back to me, you'. You changed who you're singing to halfway through. Pick the absent 'she' or the present 'you' and commit, because the listener is quietly keeping score.

  3. 03

    Zero concrete detail in three verses

    Critical

    Nothing in this song could only have happened to you. No place, no object, no specific wrong thing said. Give me the unwashed coffee cup or the text left on read. One real detail does more than a hundred 'fading memories'.

The Copy Clinic

Our paper hearts are torn apart / I knew this love would fall apart

You left your key beside the sink / It's still there. I can't make myself look.

Memories fade like falling rain / I'm drowning in this endless pain

The kettle's warm. I made two cups again. / I drink them both so neither one goes cold.

The Action Plan
  1. 1Strip every abstract noun (pain, dreams, time, memories) and force each line to name something you could photograph instead.
  2. 2Lock the perspective: choose 'you' or 'she', rewrite all three verses to that one address, and read it aloud to catch any drift.
  3. 3Rebuild the chorus around a single real object from the actual story, then test it spoken flatly with no melody to see if it still lands.
  4. 4Cut the rain metaphor and the cleverest line you have left, then replace the bridge with new information instead of a sadder rerun of the chorus.
Yours for the price of a coffee.Printed with disdain
Your turn

That was a stranger's lyrics. Drop yours, I will go just as hard.

One coffee, from €2,99. No mercy.

The trap is sincerity. You felt something real, so you assume writing it down plainly is honest. But 'I miss you and I'm sad' is not a song, it's a status update. The job is to find the one specific, slightly wrong detail that makes a stranger feel your private thing as their own. That detail is the whole craft. Everything else is rhyme scheme and luck.

How to do it right
  • 01Open on a concrete image, not a feeling. 'There's a kettle still warm in an empty house' beats 'I am so lonely tonight' every single time.
  • 02Write the chorus first and earn it second. If the hook can't survive being spoken flatly with no music, it's not a hook, it's a placeholder.
  • 03Use one specific detail per verse that only you would know. The crooked second step, the brand of cigarettes, the wrong bus. Specificity is what reads as truth.
  • 04Pick a tense and a 'you' and hold them. Decide if this already happened, is happening, or is feared, and never drift between them mid-verse.
  • 05Cut the line you're proudest of. It's usually the cleverest, the most 'writerly', and the one wearing a sign that says 'a person wrote this'.
How not to
  • Rhyming 'fire' with 'desire' and 'higher', the holy trinity of every lyric written by someone who has never had either.
  • Stacking abstract nouns until the song means nothing: 'broken dreams of fading time in shattered light'. That's four words doing zero work.
  • The placeholder 'oooh' and 'yeah' that never got replaced, now load-bearing, now 40 percent of the runtime.
  • Switching from 'she' in verse one to 'you' in verse two because you forgot who you were singing to. The listener didn't.
  • A bridge that just restates the chorus in a slightly sadder voice, as if repetition were a feeling rather than a tactic.