🎮 Game Review

Marathon

Developed by Bungie · Sony Interactive Entertainment

Extraction Shooter · PS5, Xbox Series X|S, PC · 2026-03-05

Gorgeous gunplay wrapped around a progression system that keeps deleting your reasons to care.

5.5/ 10
Cynical Sally reviews the games

Marathon shoots like a dream and asks like a loan shark. Bungie's gunfeel is, as always, genre leading, and the world looks expensive in the specific way only Bungie money looks expensive. Then the game explains that this is an extraction shooter, which means you can lose everything you bring in, and a healthy chunk of the audience quietly closed the launcher and went back to a game that lets them keep their things.

Season 2 arrived on June 2 with the Night Marsh zone, the Sentinel Runner shell, more weapons and a system to tune your shell stats, plus an Open Play Week so the curious could try the whole thing free. That is the right instinct, give people a taste, because the review bombing has not exactly slowed down. The problem is not the content. The content is good. The problem is that play beautifully, then maybe lose it all is a hard sell to anyone who wanted persistent progress.

Here is the cynical truth that is also the kind one. Marathon is one of the most technically accomplished extraction shooters ever made, and that is exactly why its identity crisis stings. A genre this punishing lives or dies on whether players trust the loop. Bungie built a Ferrari and bolted it to a slot machine, and now spends every season explaining why you should keep feeding it.

What it nails
  • 01

    Bungie's gunplay is genre leading, with a weight and feedback few shooters ever match.

  • 02

    Season 2's Night Marsh zone and Sentinel Runner shell add real, welcome variety.

  • 03

    The Open Play Week let new players try the full game and carry progress forward.

  • 04

    Production values and art direction look like the Bungie budget they clearly cost.

What it botches
  • 01

    The extraction loop drives away the players who simply want persistent progression.

  • 02

    Repeated review bombing signals a fanbase that feels misread, not just briefly annoyed.

  • 03

    The seasonal structure keeps asking for trust that the core loop keeps spending.

  • 04

    It captures the original Marathon's idea without building a memorable new identity.

Who it's for

Extraction shooter diehards who love high stakes and accept losing a loadout as the fair price of a great firefight.

Who should skip

Anyone who wants to keep what they earn and treats you might lose it all as a reason to go play something else.

Your turn

Your website, CV, or whatever you made. I'll roast that too.

A full teardown from €2,99. No mercy.

Printed with disdain · Cynical Sally