Cynical Sally← Contents
Grant Application · How to / How not to

How to Write a Grant Application (and How Not To)

Most grant applications read like a hostage note written by a committee that has never met the people it claims to serve.

By Cynical SallyIssue Nº 1

A grant application is not a love letter to your own mission. It is a business case dressed in a cardigan, and the person reading it has 60 more in the pile, a lukewarm coffee, and a scoring rubric you never bothered to read. Write for that person, not for your board.

This is what you getA real Full Truth, in full
Cynical SallyGrant Application

The Full Truth

on a small nonprofit's grant application

4.2
out of ten
You asked for $50,000 to 'empower underserved youth' and then spent 700 words avoiding the questions of how many youth, doing what, and how you would know it worked.
The Investigation
  1. 01

    The ask is buried and vague

    Critical

    The actual request ($50,000) appears on page three, after a full page of origin story. The funder's program officer decides in the first 30 seconds whether to keep reading. Lead with one sentence: who you serve, what you will do, how much you need, and the single outcome you will deliver. Everything else is supporting evidence, not throat-clearing.

  2. 02

    Outcomes are adjectives, not measurements

    Critical

    'Empower', 'uplift', and 'foster resilience' cannot be funded because they cannot be verified. You already collect attendance and a pre/post reading score, so use them. Replace the inspirational fog with '70 students, 24 weeks, 80 percent improving at least one reading level, measured by the assessment we already run in September and May'. Now you are fundable.

  3. 03

    The budget does not reconcile with the narrative

    Notable

    The narrative promises three new staff and a transportation program, but the budget shows one part-time coordinator and no transport line. A reviewer who spots one mismatch assumes the whole document is aspirational. Make every budget line trace to a sentence in the narrative, and every promise in the narrative trace to a budget line. No orphans on either side.

The Copy Clinic

For over a decade, our passionate and dedicated team has worked tirelessly to empower and uplift the underserved youth of our community, fostering resilience and creating lasting, transformational change.

We request $50,000 to keep 70 low-income students in grades 3 to 5 reading at grade level. Last year, 81 percent of our students gained at least one reading level over 24 weeks, measured by the district's own assessment.

Funds will be used to support our general operations and various programmatic activities that advance our mission throughout the year.

The $50,000 covers one full-time reading coordinator ($42,000) and weekly assessment materials for 70 students ($8,000). No funds go to indirect costs; our space and utilities are donated by the public library.

The Action Plan
  1. 1Read the funder's scoring rubric and priorities first, then rewrite your opening paragraph to answer their top criterion in their words within the first three sentences.
  2. 2Convert every 'we will empower/support/uplift' into a counted, dated, measurable outcome using data you already collect (attendance, test scores, completions).
  3. 3Rebuild the budget line by line so each number ties to a specific deliverable in the narrative, and fill the 'other funding secured' column to show you are not their only hope.
  4. 4Add a one-paragraph sustainability plan naming the specific partners and dollars that keep the program alive after this grant ends, then have one outside person who owes you nothing read the whole thing for jargon.
Yours for the price of a coffee.Printed with disdain
Your turn

That was a stranger's grant application. Drop yours, I will go just as hard.

One coffee, from €2,99. No mercy.

The good news: funders WANT to give the money away. That is literally their job. They are looking for a reason to say yes, and you keep handing them reasons to say 'next'. Stop burying the one number that matters under three paragraphs about your 'passionate, dedicated team'.

How to do it right
  • 01Open with the problem, the population, and a number. 'In our county, 1 in 4 kids ages 5 to 11 has no after-school supervision' beats any mission statement you will ever write.
  • 02Mirror the funder's own language and scoring rubric. If they fund 'measurable youth outcomes', use those exact words and then prove you can measure them.
  • 03Quantify the outcome, not the activity. Not 'we will run workshops' but 'we will move 80 kids from below-grade to at-grade reading, verified by the same assessment we already use'.
  • 04Build a budget that survives a calculator. Every line ties to a deliverable, the math adds up, and the 'other funding secured' column is not suspiciously empty.
  • 05Show the day after the grant ends. Funders fear projects that die the moment their check clears, so name your sustainability plan in concrete dollars and partners.
How not to
  • Spending paragraph one on your founding story in 2009 and the 'gap you noticed in the community', while the actual ask hides on page four.
  • Describing your team as 'passionate, dedicated, and committed', which is what every rejected applicant also wrote, in that order.
  • Promising to 'empower', 'uplift', and 'create lasting change' without a single number anyone could ever check.
  • Submitting a budget where the totals do not match the narrative, the indirect rate is mysterious, and 'miscellaneous' is your third-largest line.
  • Copy-pasting the same application to nine funders and forgetting to swap one funder's name out, which they always notice, immediately.