The Smashing Machine
Directed by Benny Safdie
Dwayne Johnson, Emily Blunt
“Dwayne Johnson stopped being The Rock long enough to actually act, and Benny Safdie turned an MMA biopic into something that hurts in all the right ways.”

Sally's not done with you yet.
Drop a URL, screenshot, or file and Sally will give you the honest truth.
The Review
Here's a sentence I never expected to write: Dwayne Johnson gives a genuinely good dramatic performance. Not 'good for The Rock' good. Actual, real, awards-consideration good. Benny Safdie's biopic of MMA legend Mark Kerr strips away every ounce of Johnson's movie star charisma and replaces it with a broken, desperate man whose body is a weapon that's slowly destroying him. The Venice Silver Lion wasn't a fluke. This is a filmmaker and an actor both operating outside their comfort zones, and the tension of that high-wire act is what makes the film crackle.
Safdie directs with the same anxious energy he brought to Uncut Gems, but applied to something more intimate and less manic. The fight sequences are brutal without being exploitative, shot tight and close so you feel every impact. Emily Blunt as Kerr's girlfriend provides the emotional anchor, and her scenes with Johnson have a rawness that suggests Safdie ran the cameras long enough for the performances to stop being performances. The Golden Globe nominations for both leads were deserved, even if the film itself got lost in the awards conversation.
The box office tells the real story: $21 million against a $50 million budget. A24 bet that Dwayne Johnson doing serious acting would sell tickets, and the audience said 'no thank you.' Which is a shame, because this is exactly the kind of risk that should be rewarded. The film isn't perfect. The second act drags when it focuses on the MMA circuit politics instead of Kerr's personal spiral, and some of the period-accurate details feel more like costume design than lived-in world-building. But as a character study of a man built to fight who can't stop fighting even when it's killing him, it's remarkably effective. Watch it on streaming. You have no excuse not to.
What It Nails
- +Dwayne Johnson is genuinely, surprisingly excellent. This isn't a vanity project. He disappears into the role
- +Fight sequences are visceral and intimate without glorifying the violence
- +Emily Blunt and Johnson have real chemistry, with scenes that feel unscripted in the best way
- +Safdie's anxious, handheld direction creates constant unease that mirrors Kerr's mental state
What It Botches
- -The second act gets lost in MMA circuit politics that are less interesting than the personal drama
- -Box office failure means most people will never see it in the format it deserves
- -Period details sometimes feel like costume design rather than lived-in authenticity
- -At two hours plus, it could lose fifteen minutes without losing anything essential

Think your work can survive this?
Drop a URL, screenshot, or file and Sally will give you the honest truth.
Who It's For
Anyone who thinks Dwayne Johnson can't act and wants to be proven wrong. MMA fans who want something deeper than highlight reels. Safdie brothers completionists.
Who Should Skip
If you want The Rock being The Rock, this will actively disappoint you. If MMA makes you queasy, the fight sequences don't pull punches. Literally.
Marketing Roast
A24 sold this as 'Dwayne Johnson like you've never seen him before,' which is accurate and also the exact reason it flopped. The audience that wants to see Johnson act doesn't overlap with the audience that goes to A24 films, and vice versa. The Venice Silver Lion couldn't bridge that gap. Now it's on streaming, where it'll find the audience it deserved all along.
External Scores

Your turn. Drop something.
Drop a URL, screenshot, or file and Sally will give you the honest truth.
