The Verdict
So you set a slasher on a remote Texas farm in the 1970s, hand a porn crew to a couple of elderly hosts, and let the dread do the cooking. I came in expecting body count, and you served me a meditation on sex, aging and desire instead. Rude. Effective, but rude.
The grindhouse aesthetic isn't just a costume here. The grain, the lurid color, the sun-baked stillness all earn their keep, and you had the nerve to make the old woman watching from the porch scarier than any knife. Mia Goth pulling double duty as both the ingenue and the killer Pearl under all that prosthetic work is the kind of swing that should have collapsed and somehow didn't.
What you really pulled off is making this the opening chapter of a whole trilogy without telegraphing it. X works on its own, but you smuggled in enough thematic rot that Pearl and MaXXXine could grow out of the same soil. That's patient. That's the opposite of how most slashers operate.
What it nails
- ▲Mia Goth in dual roles, including the elderly killer Pearl, which is a genuine acting and prosthetics flex
- ▲The 1970s grindhouse texture that feels lived-in rather than cosplayed
- ▲Turning a porn-crew premise into a real meditation on sex, aging and desire
- ▲Laying the foundation for the acclaimed A24 trilogy without bloating the standalone film
What it botches
- ▼The throwback pacing makes you wait through a lot of farm before the farm bites back
- ▼Leaning so hard on homage means some kills feel like checkboxes from older slashers
- ▼The thematic subtext occasionally announces itself louder than it needs to
- ▼Side characters in the crew exist mostly to thin the herd on schedule
Who it's for
Slasher fans who want 1970s atmosphere and an idea underneath the blood, plus anyone here to watch Mia Goth carry an entire genre.
Who should skip
If you want a fast, modern, kill-every-five-minutes slasher with no homework, the deliberate slow burn will test your patience.
The whole story lives on the hub