The Verdict
This is the one where I mostly just admire you. Ti West shot Pearl in secret, back-to-back with X, which is the kind of guerrilla audacity that should not work and absolutely did. You took a slasher origin story and wrapped it in Technicolor-styled gloss, a deliberate twisted homage to Golden Age Hollywood melodrama and The Wizard of Oz, and the contrast between that candy-colored surface and the rot underneath is the whole engine. A 76 Metascore for a horror prequel is critics quietly admitting you pulled off something rare.
Mia Goth co-wrote this and then handed in a performance that cemented her as a modern horror icon. The lengthy monologue everyone talks about is not a stunt; it is a woman watching herself realize what she is, in real time, without a single cut to hide behind. That is the kind of acting horror almost never gets credit for, and you built the entire film as a frame to hold it. Casting David Corenswet as the doomed projectionist gives the period gloss a matinee-idol face to ruin.
If I am hunting for a flaw, it is that Pearl is so locked to its central performance that the rest of the cast occasionally feels like furniture in her dollhouse. But that is almost the design: this is a portrait, not an ensemble. You made a prequel that justifies its own existence, deepened the X trilogy, and proved that a slasher can also be a sincere ode to old Hollywood. That is having your blood-soaked cake and styling it beautifully too.
What it nails
- ▲Mia Goth's co-written lead performance, including the unbroken monologue that drew major acclaim.
- ▲The Technicolor-styled homage to Golden Age Hollywood melodrama and The Wizard of Oz as horror packaging.
- ▲Shooting a full secret prequel back-to-back with X, a feat of guerrilla filmmaking audacity.
- ▲Deepening the A24 X trilogy and cementing Mia Goth as a genuine modern horror icon.
What it botches
- ▼The film is so locked to its central performance that the supporting cast can feel like set dressing.
- ▼Its portrait structure leaves little room for the ensemble dynamics a traditional slasher usually offers.
- ▼The Golden Age homage occasionally prioritizes style and tribute over forward momentum.
- ▼Viewers expecting X-style body-count slasher action may find this a slower character study instead.
Who it's for
You love a character-driven horror portrait, you came for a tour-de-force lead performance, and you appreciate old-Hollywood gloss with a knife underneath.
Who should skip
You wanted a fast, high-body-count slasher and you have no patience for a stylized melodrama built around one monologue.
The whole story lives on the hub